Was the experiment well designed ? Did it involve enough testing ? Did it involve a control group ?(core case study).
實驗是否是設計好的? 它是否有足夠的實驗結果? 它是否包含一個管理類別?(核心專題研究)
Have the data supporting the proposed hypotheses been verified ? Have the results been reproduces by other scientists ?
資料數據是否支持已被證實提出的假說? 這些結論是否已被其他的科學家推翻?
Do the conclusions and hypotheses follow logically from the data ?
結論和假說是否符合邏輯資料?
Are there no better scientific explanations ?
是否沒有更好的科學解釋?
Are the investigators unbiased in their interpretations of the results ? Are they free of a hidden agenda ? Were they funded by an unbiased source ?
研究者是否公正解釋他們的結果? 他們是否有隱藏的自由工作項目? 他們的資助來源是否公正?
Have the conclusions been verified by impartial peer review ?
結論是否由評審公平的檢閱?
Are the conclusions of the research widely accepted by other experts in this field ?
研究的結論是否能在這領域中被其他大部分專家接受?
沒有留言:
張貼留言